In previous installments of The Hotties Next Door, the Mugshot family and their twisted allies have hunted down and captured their "wayward toys," including Mrs. Taylor and her daughters. The small backwater town is a place where law and order are interpreted through the sadistic desires of local law enforcement, led by the ruthless Police Chief Kallahan and her cruel deputy, Laverne. The captives have endured brutal treatment, both at the Mugshot family home and at the hands of Chief Kallahan. The situation escalates as loyalties are tested, and an ominous Judge Dikson looms, prepared to deliver a final judgment on the captives and their tormentors.

In The Hotties Next Door 6, Police Chief Kallahan’s reign of terror continues, as she and her deputy Laverne subject Mrs. Taylor to sadistic punishment for her "crimes." Sheriff Lester, forced into complicity, begins to question his role, but it’s clear that Chief Kallahan’s cruel methods dominate. Rookie deputy Wilson learns that things in this town are far from normal, as Chief Kallahan reveals her shocking and perverse desires. Meanwhile, back at the Mugshot residence, the captured girls are once again put in their place, serving the depraved family. As tensions rise, the mysterious Preacher steps in, with an ominous Judge Dikson set to decide the fate of everyone involved in this twisted game of power and control.